How Does Traditional Marketing Mix Modeling (MMM) Work?

Jan 2, 2025

Whether you call it marketing mix modeling or media mix modeling (don’t worry – we’ll get into the difference), MMM is often positioned as a solution for marketers who want to understand the effectiveness of their marketing spend.

Great idea, right? But understanding that "effectiveness" is a difficult nut to crack:

  • Consumers engage in many behaviors that are hard to measure – online and offline.
  • Buyers are influenced by a wide variety of factors, both known and unknown. 
  • Brands can accidentally wind up measuring correlation instead of causation – someone clicked on an ad, but maybe they were going to buy regardless of the ad. How do we know? 
  • Web and mobile tech are increasingly curtailing advertiser measurement – and the threat of third-party cookie deprecation remains.

In-platform reporting and click-based attribution are two ways that marketers often measure this today.  But those solutions have their own problems:

  • Reported conversions are often double-counted across platforms, leading to overstatement of credit.
  • A click-driven methodology misrepresents channel contribution. For example, it doesn’t take into account the impact of an ad someone may have viewed and not clicked, even if they ended up converting because of the ad.

Traditional MMM – whether software you purchase or an in-house solution – tries to solve this problem through a model that illustrates correlations between consumer activity and channel spending over time. When it works, conventional MMM can:

  • Recommend media spend and optimization across channels. For example, if you’re deploying marketing budget across more than one channel, a model can provide guidance (again, based on correlation, not causation) on the optimal spend level for each channel.
  • Answer "what if?” questions and forecast business outcomes: "If we increased online spend by 20% next month, the model forecasts a 15% increase in sales."
  • Model other types of changes, like pricing or promotional strategies: "What happens if we offer a 10% discount in-store? The model predicts a 5% boost in sales.”

So: What’s the hangup? Nothing, inherently – if all you care about is correlation. Let’s get into it.

A note on media mix modeling vs. marketing mix modeling

These two terms are often used interchangeably. In practice, you can make this distinction:

  • “Media mix modeling” refers specifically to analyzing and optimizing media spend across channels (ex: TV, online, radio)
  • “Marketing mix modeling” takes a broader approach, incorporating all marketing efforts, including pricing, promotions, and other external factors that influence sales. 

How traditional MMM works

You can break down building a traditional MMM into these foundational steps:

1) Data collection. 

This includes data from across all promotional platforms, such as TV, online advertising, and in-store activities. In addition to marketing data, external factors like seasonality, economic trends, or competitive actions can be collected to enrich the dataset and calibrate more accurate modeling. Collection requires setting up infrastructure to receive and store data.

2) Data infrastructure and preparation

Data has to be clean, high-quality, and standardized to foster consistency over long periods. For example, this could involve correcting missing values, removing duplicates, and harmonizing different data formats and sources. 

3) Feature exploration and selection

Once the data is ready, the next step is to explore and identify relevant variables (features) to include in the model.

This involves determining which marketing channels, external factors, and business trends influence performance metrics like sales. Variables might include TV spend, online spend, in-store spend, seasonality, and time trends, among others.

4) Model building

With the data and features squared away, the relationships between marketing efforts (inputs) and business outcomes (outputs) are represented mathematically. MMM is often based on linear regression, but more advanced techniques, such as machine learning (ML) models, can make it easier to capture non-linear relationships or interactions between variables.

5) Model evaluation

Once the model is built, its performance must be rigorously tested. Statistical metrics can help determine how well the model explains past results and predicts future performance.

An example of a traditional MMM 

Enter: RetailCo. RetailCo is a brand that spends on TV ads, online ads (Google and Facebook), and in-store promotions. They want to determine the contribution of each channel to sales and understand where they should increase or decrease spending.

RetailCo first collects sales data over the past 12 months, together with monthly spend on TV ads, online ads, and in-store promotions. (Note: in practice, brands will typically want at least 24 months worth of data.)

Next, they build a model.

It may sound easy, but this requires significant expertise and coding to build – RetailCo might hire a team who can write Python or R to create this model. This is a resource-intensive step that generally requires several experts to develop, test, and iterate over time. 

At the end of the analysis, RetailCo ends up with an equation that includes a coefficient for each input. This coefficient (essentially a multiplier) represents how strongly an input is associated with an outcome – like sales.

It might look like this:

Based on the coefficients, RetailCo could conclude that:

  • TVsSpend, with a coefficient of 0.8, is less effective compared to Online spend.
  • Online spend is the most efficient channel. For every $1 spent, they get 1.2 units of sales.
  • In-store spend is the least effective channel.

Based on this model, they can reallocate spend levels to market more efficiently.

The resource-intensive reality of traditional MMM

MMM requires significant historical data – at least two years’ worth – to produce meaningful results. Brands don’t just have to gather the data, but also ensure that it’s consistent, complete, and accurate.

Building and maintaining a model often requires building and managing the infrastructure in-house, which demands a dedicated team. A typical team includes 8-10+ specialists such as data scientists, analysts, engineers, and product managers, all with prior experience in this domain. 

Even with the right team, achieving the same accuracy, precision, and speed as specialized third-party solutions can be tough. Businesses often spend 3-6 months just hiring and mobilizing this team, and 12-24 months iterating to optimize testing practices and processes.

Traditional MMM only gets you so far

Traditional MMM is built on correlational data, not causal relationships. And while it can help explain what happened (note: past tense) and identify trends, it doesn’t explain what specific tactics caused specific outcomes.

Much of marketing measurement relies on correlation, which can be misleading. Brands need a way to establish causation, and that means incrementality testing to determine if a decision causes an outcome.

Consider these 2 scenarios: 

  • Correlation: Your Sunday routine involves taking your kids to get ice cream. You see a billboard on your way that advertises ice cream from your favorite ice cream shop. It’s a cute ad, but you would have bought ice cream from this shop regardless. The billboard did not cause you to buy ice cream.
  • Causation: You’re running errands with your kids, and see a new billboard for an ice cream shop. The billboard makes you think you should surprise your kids with some ice cream, and so you go to that shop and buy some. The billboard caused you to buy ice cream.

Ad platforms like Meta and Google are exceptional at targeting people who are already intending to make a purchase. Their algorithms are optimized to deliver ads to the right people at the right moment. However, this doesn’t necessarily mean the ad caused the purchase – it was simply there in the face of existing intent.

Traditional MMM measures correlation. Brands need to understand causation – or might as well be lighting money on fire.

To measure causation, we use incrementality experiments. By creating control groups (who are not exposed to a treatment) and treatment groups (who are), we can establish a counterfactual: what would have happened if the marketing activity had not occurred? 

This experimental approach allows brands to isolate and measure the true lift driven by concentrated marketing tactics, offering a clear understanding of incremental impact.

Using incrementality experiments together with traditional MMM

Traditional MMM and incrementality experiments can be used together such that each tool reinforces the other – it's called a Causal MMM. With this tool, experiments can actually be used to calibrate models and improve precision using causal factors.

Traditional MMMs are generally noisy – no matter if they're SaaS or homegrown. Because they rely on observational data, the incrementality read from the traditional MMM will be uncertain, and sometimes very uncertain depending on how much signal is in the data. Additionally, since traditional MMM is so flexible, there can be multiple different sets of parameter estimates that all fit the data equally well. 

Experiments can be used to both increase precision of the model estimates as well as to help “rule out” plausible parameter sets that don’t match the incrementality tests.

Using MMM to identify possible changes in ground truth can help to structure the experimentation roadmap. You might imagine someone saying, “The MMM is indicating that Pinterest performance has improved since we released new creative. Let’s prioritize a geo test in that channel next month.”

Or, you might notice that one channel’s incrementality estimate from the MMM conflicts with data you’re seeing in your digital-tracking or last-touch model. That is a great channel to go and test!

Combining all of the information from tests and trends can be challenging, but MMMs aren’t reliable unless they’re powered by incrementality experiments – that’s the bottom line. Traditional MMMs illustrate correlations, while incrementality experiments illustrate causality. Until they’re unified in one, pairing them is your best bet for sound and trustworthy decision-making.

Better experiments, better business.

Design an incrementality experiment in minutes.

Get a Demo

Better experiments, better business.

Design an incrementality experiment in minutes.

Get a Demo

Subscribe to our newsletter

Article Tags

All blog articles

MMM Software: What Should You Look For?

Education
Mar 27, 2025

We discuss some of the key questions to ask a potential MMM provider — and the importance of prioritizing causality.

How to Know If An Incrementality Test Result Is ‘Good’ – And What to Do About It

Education
Mar 21, 2025

Plus: What to do when a test result is incremental but not profitable, and a framework for next steps after a test.

Why A Leading Economist From Amazon Came to Haus to Democratize Causal Inference

Inside Haus
Mar 19, 2025

We sit down with Principal Economist Phil Erickson to talk about Haus’ “unhealthy obsession” with productizing causal inference.

Haus x Crisp: Measure What Matters in CPG Marketing

Haus Announcements
Mar 13, 2025

When real-time retail data meets incrementality testing, CPG brands can finally measure what’s working and optimize ad spend with confidence.

Why Magic Spoon’s Former Head of Growth Embraces Incrementality at Haus

Inside Haus
Mar 10, 2025

In our first episode of Haus Spotlight, we speak to Measurement Strategist Chandler Dutton about the in-the-weeds approach Haus takes with customers.

Do YouTube Ads Perform? Lessons From 190 Incrementality Tests

From the Lab
Mar 6, 2025

An exclusive Haus analysis shows YouTube often delivers powerful new customer acquisition and retail halo effects that traditional metrics miss.

Getting Started with Causal MMM

Getting Started with Causal MMM
Education
Feb 24, 2025

Causal MMM isn’t rooted in historical correlational data – it’s rooted in causal reality.

A First Look at Causal MMM

A First Look at Causal MMM
Haus Announcements
Feb 19, 2025

Causal MMM is a new product from Haus founded on incrementality experiments. Coming 2025.

Would You Bet Your Budget on That? The Case for Honest Marketing Measurement

Would You Bet Your Budget on That? The Case for Honest Marketing Measurement
From the Lab
Feb 14, 2025

Acknowledging uncertainty enables brands to make better, more profitable decisions.

Incrementality: The Fundamentals

Incrementality: The Fundamentals
Education
Feb 13, 2025

Let's explore incrementality from every angle — what it is, what you can test, and what you need to get started.

Getting Started with Incrementality Testing

Getting Started with Incrementality Testing
Education
Feb 7, 2025

As the customer journey grows more complex, incrementality testing helps you determine the true, causal impact of your marketing.

Matched Market Tests Don't Cut It: Why Haus Uses Synthetic Control in Incrementality Experiments

Matched Market Tests Don't Cut It: Why Haus Uses Synthetic Control in Incrementality Experiments
From the Lab
Jan 28, 2025

Haus’ synthetic control produces results that are 4x more precise than those produced by matched market tests.

Incrementality School, E6: How to Foster a Culture of Incrementality Experimentation

Incrementality School, E6: How to Foster a Culture of Incrementality Experimentation
Education
Jan 16, 2025

Having the right measurement toolkit for your business is only meaningful insofar as your team’s ability to use that tool.

Geo-Level Data Now Available for Amazon Vendor Central Brands

Geo-Level Data Now Available for Amazon Vendor Central Brands
Industry News
Jan 6, 2025

Vendor Central sellers – brands that sell *to* Amazon – can now use Haus to measure omnichannel incrementality.

How Does Traditional Marketing Mix Modeling (MMM) Work?

How Does Traditional Marketing Mix Modeling (MMM) Work?
Education
Jan 2, 2025

Traditional marketing mix modeling (MMM) often relies on linear regression to illustrate correlation, not causation.

2025: The Year of Privacy-Durable Marketing Measurement

2025: The Year of Privacy-Durable Marketing Measurement
From the Lab
Dec 28, 2024

Haus incrementality testing doesn’t rely on pixels, PII, or other data that may be vulnerable to privacy regulations.

Meta Shares New Conversion Restrictions for Health and Wellness Brands

Meta Shares New Conversion Restrictions for Health and Wellness Brands
Industry News
Nov 25, 2024

Developing story: Starting in January 2025, some health and wellness brands may not be able to measure lower-funnel conversion events on Meta.

Incrementality School, E5: Randomized Control Experiments, Conversion Lift Testing, and Natural Experiments

Incrementality School, E5: Randomized Control Experiments, Conversion Lift Testing, and Natural Experiments
Education
Nov 21, 2024

Sure, the title's a mouthful – but attributing changes in data (ex: ‘my KPI went up') to certain factors (ex: ‘we increased ad spend’) is hard to do well.

Incrementality Testing: How To Choose The Right Platform

Incrementality Testing: How To Choose The Right Platform
Education
Nov 19, 2024

Whether you’re actively evaluating incrementality platforms or simply curious to learn more, consider this checklist your first stop.

Incrementality School, E4: Who Needs Incrementality Testing?

Incrementality School, E4: Who Needs Incrementality Testing?
Education
Nov 14, 2024

As brands' marketing strategies grow in complexity, incrementality testing becomes increasingly consequential.

Incrementality School, E3: How Do Brands Measure Incrementality?

Incrementality School, E3: How Do Brands Measure Incrementality?
Education
Nov 7, 2024

Traditional MTAs and MMMs won't measure incrementality – but geo experiments reveal clear cause, effect, and value.

Incrementality School, E2: What Can You Incrementality Test?

Incrementality School, E2: What Can You Incrementality Test?
Education
Oct 31, 2024

Haus’ Customer Marketing Lead Maddie Dault and Success Team Lead Nick Doren dive into what you can incrementality test – and why now's the time.

Incrementality School, E1: What is Incrementality?

Incrementality School, E1: What is Incrementality?
Education
Oct 24, 2024

To kick off our new Incrementality School series, three Haus incrementality experts weigh in describing a very fundamental concept.

Inside the Offsite: Why Haus?

Inside the Offsite: Why Haus?
Inside Haus
Oct 17, 2024

At this year's offsite, we dove into why – of all the companies, options, and career paths out there – our growing team chose Haus.

Haus Named One of LinkedIn's Top Startups

Haus Named One of LinkedIn's Top Startups
Inside Haus
Sep 25, 2024

A note from Zach Epstein, Haus CEO.

Google Announces Plan to Migrate Video Action Campaigns to Demand Gen

Google Announces Plan to Migrate Video Action Campaigns to Demand Gen
Industry News
Sep 6, 2024

The news leaves advertisers swimming in uncertainty — which is why it’s so important to test before the change.

Conversion Lag Insights: How Haus Tests Can Help Optimize Q4 Budgets

Conversion Lag Insights: How Haus Tests Can Help Optimize Q4 Budgets
From the Lab
Sep 5, 2024

Post-treatment windows offer a unique glimpse into the lingering impacts of advertising campaigns after they’ve concluded.

PMAX Experiments Revealed: Including vs. Excluding Branded Search Terms

PMAX Experiments Revealed: Including vs. Excluding Branded Search Terms
From the Lab
Aug 20, 2024

We analyzed experiments from leading brands to understand the incremental impacts of including vs. excluding branded terms in PMAX campaigns.

CommerceNext Session Recap: How Newton Baby Uses Incrementality Experiments to Maximize ROI

CommerceNext Session Recap: How Newton Baby Uses Incrementality Experiments to Maximize ROI
From the Lab
Aug 9, 2024

“We ran the test of cutting spend pretty significantly and it turns out a lot of that spend was not incremental,” says Aaron Zagha, Newton Baby CMO.

Introducing Causal Attribution: Your New Daily Incrementality Solution

Introducing Causal Attribution: Your New Daily Incrementality Solution

Causal Attribution syncs your ad platform data with your experiment results to provide a daily read on which channels drive growth.

Haus Announces $20M Raise Led by 01 Advisors

Haus Announces $20M Raise Led by 01 Advisors
Haus Announcements
Jul 30, 2024

With this additional support, Haus is well-positioned to deepen our causal inference capabilities and announce a new product: Causal Attribution.

3 Ways to Perfect Your Prime Day Marketing Strategy

3 Ways to Perfect Your Prime Day Marketing Strategy
Education
Jun 26, 2024

Think Amazon ads are the only effective marketing channel for Prime Day? Think again.

Maximize Your Q4 Growth With 4 High-Impact, Low-Risk Tests

Maximize Your Q4 Growth With 4 High-Impact, Low-Risk Tests
Education
Nov 8, 2023

Not testing during your busy season may be costing you more than you think.

Why Maturing Direct to Consumer Brands Need to Run Incrementality Tests

Why Maturing Direct to Consumer Brands Need to Run Incrementality Tests
Education
Sep 15, 2023

The media strategy that gets DTC brands from zero to one does not get them from one to ten.

5 Signs It’s Time to Invest in Incrementality

5 Signs It’s Time to Invest in Incrementality
Education
Aug 9, 2023

5 common signs that indicate it is definitely time to start investing in incrementality.

$17M Series A, Led by Insight Partners

$17M Series A, Led by Insight Partners

Haus raises $17M Series A led by Insight Partners to build the future of growth intelligence.

Why Meta's “Engaged Views” Is a Distraction, Not a Solution

Why Meta's “Engaged Views” Is a Distraction, Not a Solution
Industry News
Jul 25, 2023

While additional data can be useful, we must question whether this new rollout is truly a solution or merely another diversion.

Why You Need a 3rd Party Incrementality Partner

Why You Need a 3rd Party Incrementality Partner
Education
Jul 6, 2023

Are you stuck wondering if you should be using 3rd party incrementality studies, ad platform lift studies, or trying to design your own? Find out here.

iOS 17 Feels Like iOS 14 All Over Again. What It Means for Growth Marketing…And Does It Matter Anymore?

iOS 17 Feels Like iOS 14 All Over Again. What It Means for Growth Marketing…And Does It Matter Anymore?
Industry News
Jun 12, 2023

A single press release vaguely confirmed that Apple will continue its assault on user level attribution. Here, I unpack what I think it means for growth marketing.

How Automation Is Transforming Growth Marketing

How Automation Is Transforming Growth Marketing
Education
May 30, 2023

As platforms force more automation, the role of the media buyer is evolving. Read on to learn what to expect and what levers are left to pull.

Statistical Significance Is Costing You Money

Statistical Significance Is Costing You Money
From the Lab
Apr 13, 2023

It is profitable to ignore statistical significance when making marketing investments.

The Secret to Comparing Marketing Performance Across Channels

The Secret to Comparing Marketing Performance Across Channels
Education
Mar 2, 2023

While incrementality is better than relying on attribution alone, comparing them as-is is challenging. Thankfully, there’s a better way to get an unbiased data point regardless of the channel.

Your Attribution Model Is Precise but Not Accurate - Here’s Why

Your Attribution Model Is Precise but Not Accurate - Here’s Why
Education
Feb 8, 2023

Learn which common marketing measurement tactics are accurate, precise, neither or both.

How to Use Causal Targeting to Save Money on Promotions

How to Use Causal Targeting to Save Money on Promotions
Education
Feb 1, 2023

Leverage causal targeting to execute promotions that are actually incremental for your business.

Are Promotions Growing Your Business or Losing You Money?

Are Promotions Growing Your Business or Losing You Money?
Education
Feb 1, 2023

Promotions, despite their potential power and ubiquity, are actually hard to execute well.

User-Level Attribution Is Out. Geo-Testing Is the Future.

User-Level Attribution Is Out. Geo-Testing Is the Future.
Education
Jan 27, 2023

Geotesting is a near-universal approach for measuring the incremental effects of marketing across both upper and lower funnel tactics.

The Haus Viewpoint

The Haus Viewpoint
Inside Haus
Jan 18, 2023

We are building Haus to democratize access to world-class decision science tools.